My comments on this might ruffle a few feathers! Jeet Kune Do is being referred to by
some as MMA (Mixed Martial Arts). MMA was created primarily as a contact sport for
competition use! Jeet Kune Do is a structured, legitimate system of martial art, not a
hodgepodge conglomeration of a little bit of this and a little bit of that. Some believe
that since a statement exists (made by Bruce Lee) that Jeet Kune Do consists primarily of
Wing Chun Gung Fu, European fencing and Western boxing, that Jeet Kune Do is a
mixed martial art. If this were true, anyone could go out and learn Wing Chun, fencing
and boxing and know Jeet Kune Do, but guess what? It doesn’t work that way! It was
the reality based mindset and creative genius of Bruce Lee that created Jeet Kune Do.
That is what makes Jeet Kune Do such an effective system of fighting, rather that just a
mix and match martial arts method. Jeet Kune Do is about efficiently and systematically
destroying the threat in front of you, not rolling around with someone trying to get
them to tap out! There is no gi (or spandex), no mats, no bare feet and no gloves when
the street is your reality. There is, however, bare knuckles, street clothes, street shoes
and whatever surface you are forced to deal with … oh, and no tapping out or quitting!
There is no title, belt or cash reward to be gained, but instead the God given right to
continue living! The mindset is completely different!
This whole Jeet Kune Do/MMA controversy has spawned other negativity towards Jeet
Kune Do among those in the sports related martial arts community. Many of them are
saying that we use the excuse that Jeet Kune Do is “too deadly” for the ring, saying that
we are actually scared of contact, so we use that as an excuse to keep from participating
in UFC type matches. That analogy has more holes in it than Swiss cheese! Jeet Kune Do
was born out of contact oriented training, with sparring being one of our primary
training methods. We do wear more protective gear than what you see in the MMA
events, but that is so we can “keep it real”, as the saying goes! Also, we spar with shoes
on our feet, and that brings a whole different degree of contact to our training. It makes
the sparring much more realistic and closer to what we would encounter in the street.
We do have what is commonly referred to as a “kickboxing” phase to our training,
where we wear protective gear and basically restrict our movements to punching and
kicking. Normal gear includes finger gloves or boxing gloves, head guard with Face
cage, hard style shin guards and a groin cup. This is done with the understanding that
the lead hand punch could just as easily be a finger jab to the eyes, and that the kick to
the shin/knee area with the protective gear on (street hockey or professional catcher’s
shin guards) would be more penetrating if delivered for real. This approach brings a
definite realism to our sparring, and helps us prepare for the harsh reality of the streets.
Regardless of who you are, you cannot deny the raw effectiveness of the finger jab to
the eyes and the solid kick to the groin. Some have made the statement that they could
take the kick to the groin and keep going, but that is definitely not true, especially with
the intention for full contact with the Jeet Kune Do groin kick! To make this clearer,
recently in an MMA fight, one fighter “accidentally” kicked another fighter in the groin.
Not only was he down and unable to continue, but further examination proved that his
left testicle had “exploded” on impact!
I am not saying that principles from Jeet Kune Do cannot be applied in a sport martial
arts environment. The greatest karate fighter of all time, Joe Lewis, trained privately
with Bruce Lee for several years. He used many of Bruce Lee’s principles and tactics in
the ring and it made him a much more effective fighter. This proves that Jeet Kune Do
training can make a more effective competition fighter, but the mentality is different. Of
course we know that you cannot go into the ring with plans to break someone’s leg and
jab their eyes, so Jeet Kune Do as it is originally intended cannot be adopted as a whole!